no longer supports Internet Explorer.

To browse and the wider internet faster and more securely, please take a few seconds to  upgrade your browser .

Enter the email address you signed up with and we'll email you a reset link.

  • We're Hiring!
  • Help Center

paper cover thumbnail

Article review writing format, steps, examples and illustration PDF Compiled by Mohammed Yismaw

Profile image of Muhammed Yismaw

2021, Article review writing format, steps, examples and illustration PDF Compiled by Mohammed Yismaw

The purpose of this document is to help students and researchers understand how a review of an academic journal is conducted and reported in different fields of study. Review articles in academic journals that analyze or discuss researches previously published by others, rather than reporting new research results or findings. Summaries and critiques are two ways to write a review of a scientific journal article. Both types of writing ask you first to read and understand an article from the primary literature about your topic. The summary involves briefly but accurately stating the key points of the article for a reader who has not read the original article. The critique begins by summarizing the article and then analyzes and evaluates the author’s research. Summaries and critiques help you learn to synthesize information from different sources and are usually limited to two pages maximum.

Related Papers

Harald von Kortzfleisch , Christoph Kahle

Neue Technologien und Innovationen stellen heutzutage wichtige Schlüsselelemente der Wachstums und Erfolgssicherung von Unternehmen dar. Durch einen in Geschwindigkeit und Intensität immer schneller zunehmenden Wettbewerb nehmen Innovationen eine immer zentralere Rolle im Praxisalltag von Unternehmen ein. Dieser technische Fortschritt treibt auch in der Wissenschaft das Thema des Innovationsmanagements in den letzten Jahrzehnten immer stärker voran und wird dort ausgiebig diskutiert. Die Bedeutung von Innovationen wächst dabei ebenfalls aus der Sicht der Kunden, welche heutzutage viel differenzierter als früher Produkte und Dienste nachfragen und somit Unternehmen vor neue Herausforderungen stellen. Überdies stellen Innovationen heute ein entscheidendes Bindeglied zwischen Marktorientierung und erhofften Unternehmenserfolg dar. Seit einigen Jahren lässt sich eine Öffnung der Unternehmensgrenzen für externe Quellen wie Kunden, Zulieferer, Universitäten oder teilweise auch M...

example of journal article review pdf

SSRN Electronic Journal

Helmut Krcmar

Dominic Lindner

Alexandra Waluszewski

Research Policy

Nuria Gonzalez Alvarez

Creativity and Innovation Management

Matti Pihlajamaa

Firms tap into user knowledge to learn about the users’ needs. While users have been recognized as a valuable source of knowledge for innovation, few studies have investigated how their knowledge is integrated into innovation processes in the context of complex products and systems (CoPS). The purpose of this study is to reveal the practices of CoPS manufacturers to facilitate user knowledge utilization for innovation. We investigate two case companies, a medical device manufacturer and an aircraft manufacturer, and report on seven managerial practices for utilizing user knowledge. We adopt the absorptive capacity model in structuring our findings and elaborate three of the model's sub-capabilities (recognition of the value of user knowledge, acquisition of user knowledge, and assimilation/transformation of user knowledge) by proposing that each is associated with a distinct managerial goal and related practices: (1) Sensitizing the organization to the innovation potential of user knowledge, (2) identifying and gaining access to suitable user knowledge, and (3) analyzing and interpreting user knowledge and integrating it into product development. Our study contributes to the innovation management literature by analyzing the capabilities required to utilize user knowledge throughout the CoPS innovation process.

Information & Management

Diffusion of digital technologies into the manufacturing industry has created new opportunities for innovation that firms must address to remain competitive. We investigate the role of customer and user knowledge in the digital innovation processes of three global B2B manufacturing companies. We find that the B2B manufacturing industry's characteristics influence how users and customers may be leveraged. Customers making the purchasing decisions are considered for knowledge about short-term changes in market needs, while users working directly with the products provide long-term guidance for digital innovation. We identify practices for acquiring, distributing, and using customer and user knowledge for digital innovation.

Journal of business market management

Patricia Sandmeier

Journal of Entrepreneurship, Management and Innovation

Journal of Entrepreneurship, Management and Innovation JEMI

Given the rising role of users in innovation processes and the increasing amount of research in this field the aim of this paper is to explore the limits of our understanding of the user innovation (UI) concept. In doing so, the study addresses four basic questions: (1) Why do users create and share innovation? (2) Who is the user-innovator? (3) What type of innovation do users create? (4) How do users innovate? The results of a systematic literature review identified the main research streams on user innovation, together with weaknesses of past research and perspectives for future studies.


Gernot Grabher

Journal of Computer‐ …

Petra Schubert , Kathrin Möslein

Mossimo Sesom

Shahab Zare

Arthur Shulman

International Journal of Technology Management

Richard Farr

European Journal of Dental Education


Chandra Yanto

Management Science

John Roberts

Maria Antikainen

Johanna Bragge

Ivona Vrdoljak Raguz

Service Science

Tuure Tuunanen

Jouni K Juntunen

Benji Decker

Eva Heiskanen

Handbook of Marketing

Jerome Hauser

Service Industries Journal

Christian Kowalkowski

Journal of Engineering Design

Ola Isaksson , Anna Rönnbäck

Journal of Management

Bettina Bastian

International Journal of Innovation Management

Harald von Kortzfleisch

Guido H Baltes

Technology Analysis & Strategic Management

Raimo Lovio

Marco Bertoni , Christian Johansson

Dominik Walcher

Managing Service Quality

Tor W. Andreassen

Journal of Product Innovation Management

Gary Schirr

System Sciences, 2004. …

Ralf Reichwald , Dominik Walcher

Edina Vadovics

Jouni Similä

Luis Cancino Muñoz

Shell Artillery

Ralf Reichwald

Journal of the Academy of …

Ian Wilkinson , Subroto Roy

16+ Article Review – Examples, PDF

Article review, 1. journal article review form, 2. article review & critique, 3. formal article review, 4. article review guideline, 5. book and article reviews, 6. format for review article, 7. scientific article review, 8. critical reviews of journal articles, 9. research experience article review, 10. review for article psychological bulletin, 11. article format guide review, 12. value of review article, 13. articles for peer-review publications, 14. law review article selection process, 15. creative article review, 16. club article review, 17. review of research articles, what is an article review, how to write an article review, what is the difference between an article review and a literature review, can i use first-person sentences in an article review, should i include the abstract of the article in my review, how long should an article review be.

journal article review form

Choose the article to review

Read the article carefully, identify the main points and key arguments, evaluate the article’s methodology and research design, assess the article’s strengths and weaknesses, write a summary of the article, write the main body of the review, conclude with a final evaluation and recommendations for improvement, proofread and edit the review, more business, 79+ formal letter examples & samples in pdf | doc | microsoft word | apple pages | google docs, 28+ examples of sports certificate in publisher | ms word | psd | ai | pages | indesign, 65+ project proposal examples in pdf | ms word | pages | google docs, 8+ reminder email examples & samples in pdf | doc, 85+ report examples in pdf, 7+ formal email examples and samples in pdf | doc, 27+ email examples & samples in microsoft word | apple pages | editable pdf | google docs, 10+ goodbye emails to coworkers examples & samples in word, 17+ leave application email examples & samples in pdf | doc, 58+ incident report examples & samples in pdf | google docs | pages | doc, 4+ introduction email examples & samples – pdf, doc, 38+ business proposal letter examples in pdf | doc | microsoft word | apple pages, related articles.

Example of an article review - PDF file

Example of an article review - PDF file

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

I)agc I ir l'-iFaculfy <strong>of</strong> Agriculture <strong>an</strong>d []nl'ironmcnt ScicnccsAGE(l-491 -001 Research & MethodologrPr<strong>of</strong>. Paul 'fhomassinArticle ReviewC'ore luttctions ol' a rescarch proposal <strong>an</strong>d the c()mnlon clraw'backs expcricnccdduring the writing process are the ntain topics <strong>of</strong> part I <strong>an</strong>d p<strong>an</strong> II <strong>of</strong> Proposals thatworl

I)age I ol'lIn ;rrtt't II rtl'Proposals that work. the luthor Ircscllts grridclincs t'trr solringc()nln)ot) prrlhlcttts r)ccurrillg uhert prcpariltg a rescarch pr()p()sal. Ihe lirst sr-'ries ol'adrices hrousltt lirrltarel c()rlcerns thc sceluellcc ()l'action leading up 1o the: actual nriting..'\lthough ttot linear. this process has scveral milcstoncs that lirlkrn a logical order.Bclbre cottsidering several altcrnative nrcthods <strong>of</strong> incluirl', it is crucial to clcarll' statc thcnature <strong>of</strong> the problem -L/ V.6h,author puts as "n'hat tlo I rv<strong>an</strong>t to knou'?") <strong>an</strong>clsun'eying relev<strong>an</strong>t literature. Through this process, great care nlust be taken in evaluatingthe scientit-rc rele\,'<strong>an</strong>ce <strong>of</strong> the topic, assessing the reason behind the presence <strong>of</strong> a gap inknorvledge <strong>an</strong>d <strong>an</strong>ticipating all possible ovtWJA."//The author also underlines the difference between original <strong>an</strong>d initial research. A//,/:"' ,{.,:,common mistake made by neophytes is to believe that original scientific research doesnot include replication or cross-yalidation. From replicating or cross-validating paststudies, new questions c<strong>an</strong> emerge. By creating nerv area <strong>of</strong> studies, such endeavourcontributes to the exp<strong>an</strong>sion <strong>of</strong> the body <strong>of</strong> knorvledge ury$ome original research.In the second section <strong>of</strong> part II, the author elaborates on the challenges <strong>of</strong> style<strong>an</strong>d form in writing a proposal. After underlining the import<strong>an</strong>ce <strong>of</strong> objectivity, the authorprovides some guidelines regarding the use <strong>of</strong> quotations. The general rule put fonvardby Locke is that no quotation should be use unless it c<strong>an</strong> not be ppplr *,e without losingits subst<strong>an</strong>ce. Otherwise. the writer risks the alienation <strong>of</strong> its audience.i't':,-^t ' tlir

l)uqc i ol'lIltc ittttltor thctt Lttltlress thc issuc r)f s]'stenr l<strong>an</strong>guagc {r.s()pp()seto c()ltinl(rtl'l his c()llcept re lL'rs to 3 fr,y4t'rrt'uorcls lirund in scientilrc litcrurturc thut haic iur,/ttteitninc rrithin l ili/plinc.S1'stcnr l<strong>an</strong>guage thcrelirrc has a high lcrcl ol'<strong>an</strong>d elitttinatcs tlic risk ol'cortrniunication lirilurc bctrvecn thc uritcr <strong>an</strong>d hisAfier providing a guide to the use <strong>of</strong> s1'stern l<strong>an</strong>guage, Lockc redirects thcdiscussion tou'ards the editing <strong>of</strong> thc proposal zurd the choice <strong>of</strong> a title. The allthor./underline the irnport<strong>an</strong>ce <strong>of</strong> seeking editorial revisigxftrom a colleague <strong>an</strong>d reading thedocument in reversal so as to identify <strong>an</strong>y mech<strong>an</strong>ical errors left unnoticed. As for thet/.f.r'.t:.title, its fund<strong>an</strong>f{ialpurpose is to identify content for future retrieval by the academic/communiry.wVariables studiecl, model used, data treatment performed or the purpose <strong>of</strong>the research are all elements that are eligible for inclusion in tlyttitle. Clear <strong>an</strong>d concisecommunication <strong>of</strong> the research topic is the objective to purruV(hen choosing a title.The final section <strong>of</strong> part II focuses on the content <strong>of</strong> the proposal. The authorsuggests the use <strong>of</strong> a pilot study to confirm the validity <strong>of</strong> the experirnental design. Healso advocates for the preparation <strong>of</strong> contingency pl<strong>an</strong>s should foreseeable rnishapsoccur during the data collection <strong>an</strong>d treatment processes. Regarding the section <strong>of</strong> theproposal dedicated to the <strong>an</strong>alysis <strong>of</strong> the results, Locke argues that it should be presentedaccording to the objectives <strong>of</strong> the research set forth at the beginning <strong>of</strong> the proposal.Finally, he discusses the import<strong>an</strong>ce <strong>of</strong> underst<strong>an</strong>ding the St{tistical l<strong>an</strong>guage <strong>an</strong>delaborates on what is scientific truth.J'..L"ip

PDF: Municipal Food Policy in light of Federal and Provincial Policy

Extended embed settings


You have already flagged this document. Thank you, for helping us keep this platform clean. The editors will have a look at it as soon as possible.

Mail this publication

Delete template.

Are you sure you want to delete your template?

For this magazine there is no download available

Magazine: Example of an article review - PDF file

Save as template?


example of journal article review pdf

Choose your language

Main languages

Further languages

Performing this action will revert the following features to their default settings:

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!


  1. 💌 Academic article review example. 39 Best Literature Review Examples

    example of journal article review pdf

  2. (PDF) Peer review of scientific papers

    example of journal article review pdf

  3. Journal Article Review Template / (PDF) Using a Template to Facilitate

    example of journal article review pdf


    example of journal article review pdf

  5. Journal Article Review Template / (PDF) Using a Template to Facilitate

    example of journal article review pdf

  6. Critical Review of A Journal Article

    example of journal article review pdf


  1. English presentation journal article review 2207

  2. Journal Article Analysis



  5. Reading Journal Articles Efficiently!

  6. How to analyse PAPERS and JOURNAL ARTICLES


  1. What Are Some Examples of Feature Articles?

    Feature articles look at news stories in-depth rather than delivering breaking news. One example is a human interest story that discusses someone’s experiences. Other feature article examples include:

  2. A Comprehensive Guide to APA Formatting Help

    APA formatting is a common style of writing used in academic and professional settings. It is often used for research papers, journal articles, and other documents. The first step in getting started with APA formatting is to familiarize you...

  3. What Is Continuous Prose?

    Continuous prose is a piece of written work with text flowing from one paragraph to the next without subheads. Examples of continuous prose include essays, newspaper articles, journal articles, blog posts and research papers.

  4. Article review writing format, steps, examples and illustration PDF

    The purpose of this document is to help students and researchers understand how a review of an academic journal is conducted and reported in different

  5. Sample Format For Reviewing A Journal Article

    Sample format, Page 1 of 2. Sample Format For Reviewing A Journal Article. Reading and summarizing a research article in the behavioral or medical sciences

  6. 16+ Article Review

    journal article review form Details. File Format. PDF.


    PDF | On Mar 24, 2021, Babaaradio Kombui published ARTICLE REVIEW | Find, read and cite ... International Journal of Educational Technology,.

  8. Journal Article Critique Example

    The research problem being addressed is whether public administrators are free from accountability for their decisions and what are the different influences

  9. Review Article

    Literature reviews provide a summary of what the authors.

  10. Scientific Article Review

    Summaries and critiques are two ways to write a review of a scientific journal article. Both types of writing ask you first to read and understand an


    They should have examples of journal articles reviews from my General

  12. Example of an article review

    Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software. START NOW. I)agc I ir l'-iFaculfy <strong>of</

  13. Article review example apa pdf

    Apa article review format. Journal article reviews refer to the appraisal of potencies and limitations of an article's opinion and subject matter. The article

  14. Reviewing a Journal Article (Peer Review)

    For example, it is particularly challenging for an Action Editor if a reviewer lauds a manuscript in the written review but then chooses “major revisions” or. “